
Online debates about celebrity work culture sparked when KATSEYE’s Megan Skindiel , who is recovering from a concussion, recently performed seated and in sunglasses during a show in Austin on the group’s WILDWORLD Tour. The next night in Dallas, video surfaced of the artist taking part in the group’s intense dance choreography, while wearing what many speculate to be a heart monitor .
Fans expressed grave concern for her well-being, questioning whether she should be performing at all. While it is important to note that we don’t actually know whether it was Megan’s own decision to perform, many still accused KATSEYE’s label, HYBE x Geffen Records, of potentially overworking their artists at the expense of their health. The label is a partnership between the South Korean entertainment company HYBE (home to groups like BTS, Illit, TXT, and Seventeen) and the American label Geffen Records (home to artists such as Olivia Rodrigo, Selena Gomez, Lady Gaga, and Lana Del Rey).
And there’s another relevant context: With Manon and Sophia already on hiatus, Megan’s absence would leave the group with just three members, only half their original formation of six, and for that reason the group had already postponed three shows . As of now, neither the label nor the group has publicly addressed the criticism.
For longtime K-pop fans, none of this is entirely shocking. Those who follow the industry have most likely already witnessed their idols push through panic attacks , fainting spells , extreme sleep deprivation , injuries from falls , and many other mental and physical struggles in order to give their fans the concert experience they were promised. But for many Western fans, this may be the first look at the grueling expectations that the K-pop world has for its artists, which helps explain the intense concern in their reactions.
KATSEYE is an especially interesting case for us to explore this friction. The group was formed through Dream Academy, a survival competition run by HYBE and Geffen Records, where the finalists trained mainly in Los Angeles, with trips to HYBE’s headquarters in Seoul. While KATSEYE’s music is mostly in English, the group promotes in both the U.S. and South Korea, exemplifying the group’s unique positioning between the two music industries, each with its own set of rules and ideas of what a pop career demands.
Commercially, that meeting point keeps getting closer, with the dramatic rise of K-pop’s popularity and its growing presence in mainstream Western media. And that cross-cultural exchange is reflected in the music itself: English words increasingly make up the majority of the lyrics in K-pop songs, and many labels are now intentionally debuting members who are proficient in English.
It also helps to compare how music careers get built, starting with how the artists are even first discovered by the world. Many of the West’s biggest stars began as those who were organically noticed: Justin Bieber was discovered through cover videos on YouTube, and Taylor Swift was spotted as a teenager playing Nashville’s Bluebird Cafe. K-pop runs on a completely different model: one where the company trains the individua l into being an artist through a strict, meticulous formula within a larger system of strategic control.
Those who make it through the company’s insanely competitive rounds of auditions will then spend years as trainees with no guarantee of debuting. Those years typically involve regular evaluations, private lessons, as well as sometimes group living for management and surveillance purposes. Trainees often agree to be prescribed diet plans and sometimes even cosmetic surgery , as well as close monitoring of their private lives including harsh restrictions on dating and phone use to ensure that their status as trainees remains a secret. And what may be even more jarring for those new to this culture is that many of these trainees are often as young as 13 , with more and more labels debuting their idols before they are even close to being legal adults.
In exchange comes a carefully engineered shot at success, with executives and experts calibrating the exact combination of members, visual concept, songs, and more to optimize audience appeal. Audiences got a glimpse of this process during Dream Academy , though in a more Westernized version. Whatever ethical questions this process raises, it works, at least commercially. All the biggest K-pop groups have come out of this exact system, and the labels continue to stay closely involved throughout their careers.
But the label isn’t the only relationship that heavily shapes a K-pop artist’s life. There’s also the one with the fans. Western audiences are no strangers to fan culture, from Beatlemania to Swifties, and plenty of domestic K-pop fandoms have a U.S. counterpart. However, one notable cultural difference is one of degree. Take whatever you’ve seen from American fandoms and multiply it by a hundred, and you start to approach the level of devotion an average K-pop stan extends to their bias, or favorite member. They follow idols to concert after concert and every public appearance in between, and they also work together, using step-by-step guides to stream songs in ways that send them up the charts, sometimes even outperforming many mainstream Western artists on global charts like the Billboard Hot 100 .
And that kind of devotion comes with expectations. Many groups have dedicated fan-chatting apps, such as HYBE’s Weverse and the subscription-based Bubble, where artists can post and chat with fans almost directly, and fans come to expect regular contact through this service. Idols are also expected to keep up a cheerful image, to avoid canceling a show that fans paid for at all costs, and to immediately apologize when they fall short, even when the reason is an injury.
Public dating, meanwhile, has long been treated as a career-threatening betrayal for these artists. In 2024, after aespa’s Karina was revealed to be dating an actor, she faced a wave of backlash, causing her to post a handwritten apology to fans . Norms have loosened for established stars, but newcomers, or what the industry calls shin-ins, are discouraged, or often barred from it, by both their companies and their fans.
Because they’re still largely construed as Western artists, KATSEYE is, to a large degree, exempt from these rules. For example, members have been comparatively open about their dating lives—a luxury a Korea-based group would most likely not be afforded. But KATSEYE is still managed by a K-pop company, trained by a K-pop system. It wouldn’t be surprising that some of that ethos of always putting the fans first is internalized within the group’s own decision-making, shaping how much they feel they owe their fans in ways a Western artist might not.
From a Western perspective, it makes sense why all of this might feel like an oppressive system that needs reform, or even dismantling. And the criticism exists internally as well: On November 16, South Korea’s Culture Ministry officially announced the launch of a comprehensive survey to review concerns over young performers’ working conditions following the NewJeans controversy. However, one could argue that Western criticism can often be translated by domestic fans as a kind of white-savior complex, with “outsiders” interfering in the methods and systems that have existed without their attention for decades, while deciding it must assimilate to their terms and standards. Especially when many of these critics lack the necessary understanding of the complicated nuances of how K-pop’s cultural specificity largely reflects South Korea’s distinct historical, political, and socioeconomic landscape—one that dramatically differs from the U.S.
These aspects of K-pop are deeply normalized within the industry itself: Trainee systems are shown openly in documentaries and TV series, including ones the companies themselves help produce, and artists often talk about those years candidly , suggesting that many of them may not see these practices as the problem outsiders do. And maybe there is also a truth in the idea that K-pop’s impressive commercial success is partly a product of the very controls critics object to, including the symbiotic relationships between artists and their labels, and between artists and their fans. Without that culture, we would probably not have what we now know to be BLACKPINK or BTS.
None of this makes the overworking of artists acceptable, nor does it erase much of the valid concern so many people feel. We are allowed to worry when our favorite artist seems to be pushed too far, whether it’s by their own drive, their label’s instructions, or by the weight of fans’ expectations. And we’re allowed to question the very systems that make that possible—in K-pop, in Hollywood, or anywhere else.
But it’s also worth asking what it might mean for a system with decades of independent history—one that grew largely outside Western norms—to navigate a global spotlight (and the equally globalized standards that come with it). Where does cultural context end and basic safety begin? And who gets to decide what “better” looks like, if not the artists living it?
Why Did Joe and Tatiana Break Up? Here’s the Deal
Sooooo, Are the Stars of ‘Campus Drivers’ Dating?
William’s Plotting a Secret Royal Xmas Meeting
Is Robert Pattinson Hollywood’s Last Leading Man?
Meet the ‘Sunrise on the Reaping’ Cast Partners
Wait, Was Kylie Jenner at the Governors Awards?
Maura Higgins Forced to Postpone ‘DWTS’ Rehearsals
Source: Entertainment