Crime

Mom, 18, Was Stabbed 120 Times in 1966 as Her Baby Slept Nearby. Now a Family Friend Has Been Convicted

Mom, 18, Was Stabbed 120 Times in 1966 as Her Baby Slept Nearby. Now a Family Friend Has Been ConvictedKC BakerMon, November 16, 2026 at 11:21 PM UTC

James Barbier leaving courtCredit: WGN News/YouTube

New mother Karen Snider was at her Illinois home with her 2-month-old daughter when James Barbier came over on Nov. 12, 1966

Barbier was friends with Snider and her husband Paul Snider, 23, so she let him inside, prosecutors said

According to police, Barbier then stabbed Snider 125 times, piercing her heart and lungs

James Barbier was a pall bearer at Karen Snider’s funeral in 1966.

Now, 60 years later, Barbier, 81, of St. Louis County, Mo., has been found guilty of killing the 18-year-old mother as her baby daughter slept nearby in the Illinois home she shared with her husband.

On Monday, Nov. 9, a jury convicted Barbier of first-degree murder for stabbing her more than 120 times in her home in Calumet City, a suburb of Chicago, ABC 7 Chicago, CNN and the Chicago Tribune reported.

“I hope that he never gets to breathe air outside again,” said Snider’s daughter, Paula Larson, who was just 2 months old when her mother was killed, per the Chicago Tribune. “He didn’t give my mother a choice, and he got to live his life for 60 years.”

Snider was killed on Nov. 12, 1966, while her husband Paul Snider, then 23, was at work at the Indiana Harbor Belt Railroad, said Cook County Assistant State’s Attorney Krystyn Dilillo during the trial’s closing arguments.

Barbier, who lived in Gary at the time, was friends with Snider and her husband, the prosecutor said, CNN reported. He worked with her husband and knew his schedule, Dilillo added.

“Karen let him in her home, her friend, and that’s when it all broke bad,” Dilillo said, per the outlet. “He pulled out his weapon and plunged it into her body 125 times.”

Barbier stabbed Snider over and over again in the neck and chest, as well as her heart, liver and lungs, police said, according to ABC 7.

She had defensive wounds on her hands, the outlet reported, citing the autopsy report.

“She put up a fight. She tried to save her life,” Dilillo said, per the Chicago Tribune. “But she lost that fight. He won.”

Snider was found dead when her husband returned home from work at about 11 p.m. that night, police said, CBS reported.

Want to keep up with the latest crime coverage? Sign up for PEOPLE’s free True Crime newsletter for breaking crime news, ongoing trial coverage and details of intriguing unsolved cases.

Their 2-month-old baby was sleeping in her bassinet.

“Police said Snider told them he found his wife’s body, her clothes in disarray, in their second floor bedroom,” according to a 1966 United Press International (UPI) story CBS published in a 2024 report about Barbier’s arrest.

Police had few clues to go on other than blood spatter on a broken basement window, UPI reported at the time.

When Barbier returned home that night, his wife said he seemed nervous and had cuts and blood on him, according to the state’s attorney’s office, per CNN.

His wife said he put his clothes right in the washing machine, something he never usually did, according to CNN, citing prosecutors.

People noticed cuts on Barbier at Snider’s funeral, prosecutors said, per the outlet. He was arrested in 1966 but not charged.

The case went cold until 2022, when a man came forward saying he remembered his grandmother talking about the murder and called police, WGN9 reported.

Detectives reopened the case and tested evidence left behind at the crime scene for DNA, which identified Barbier as a suspect.

He was arrested in the spring of 2024 at his home in Creve Coeur, Mo., according to the state’s attorney’s office.

Paula Larson, whose father died in 1989, is grateful for the verdict.

“So many people have died in these 60 years,” she said, per the Chicago Tribune. “All that remains is the small family we have. And this is so very important to come to this verdict before we lost anybody else.”

Barbier will be sentenced on Dec. 15.


Source: Crime

More in Crime →